All writing

Ideas

The Soul Nudge: The Anxiety That's Always Worth It

Two feelings we call anxiety, how to tell them apart, and why one of them is always worth following.

My sister Jaime Cornell walking down a dirt road through green hills in El SalvadorEl Salvador · © Danielle Posa

My sister, Jaime Cornell, in El Salvador.

My favorite hours of the week are early on Saturday and Sunday mornings, before anyone needs anything from me. I spend them in what I call my thinking corner: a spot on my couch where I sit with my coffee, the sun comes in, and I can look out the window. I read, I reflect, and slowly I get past the noise in my head to something quieter. This morning I was reading Roger Housden's Ten Poems to Change Your Life and sitting with two of the poems side by side: Mary Oliver's "The Journey" and Kabir's "The Time Before Death," in Robert Bly's version.

One was written by a fifteenth-century Indian mystic, the other by a twentieth-century American poet, and they say something remarkably similar. Oliver writes about the day someone finally knows what they have to do and begins, even while the voices around them beg them to stay. Kabir is even more urgent. If you're waiting for some kind of salvation at the end of your life, he says, you've misunderstood. "What is found now is found then."

I love when that happens. When two voices from completely different worlds arrive at the same truth, it tells me how deep that truth runs. Both poems are asking us to wake up to who we really are, and to live fully and passionately now, while we can. Both describe a moment I've come to think of as a soul nudge. I'm not the first to call it that, and I love that others have found the same words for it. What I want to offer is a way to tell it apart from the anxiety that holds us back.

Two feelings we call anxiety

But anyone who has tried to wake up to their life knows it isn't comfortable. Choosing to live more truthfully stirs something in us that can feel a lot like anxiety. And I think it's worth slowing down here, because there are two very different feelings we call anxiety, and most of us have never been taught to tell them apart.

The first is the anxiety that holds us back. It comes from living a small life: feeling disconnected from ourselves and our values, making choices that don't feel right. It shows up when we're in a job that isn't who we are, or a relationship that isn't who we are, or when we've stopped expanding and let fear make our decisions. Those fears are protective. They don't come from the heart, and they aren't connected to the inner genius each of us carries. At its worst, this anxiety is crippling. This anxiety asks you to shrink. It's quiet and constant, and it's easy to mistake for simply being an adult.

The second is the discomfort of expansion. It comes with making bold moves: booking the trip to the place that frees your soul, leaving the job you've outgrown, showing up in the world in a bigger, more expansive way. It can feel like anxiety. Your heart pounds. You question yourself. But underneath it is the feeling of the self expanding. When it comes from living more passionately and boldly, with integrity, that discomfort is always worth it.

The anxiety that holds you back

Protective and fear-led. Comes from a life out of alignment with who you are.

It asks you to shrink.

The discomfort of expansion

Heart-led and true. Comes from bold moves made with integrity.

It asks you to grow.

The research supports this in an interesting way. Alison Wood Brooks at Harvard Business School found that people who told themselves "I am excited" before a stressful performance, like public speaking or singing in front of others, did better than people who tried to calm down. Anxiety and excitement are both states of high arousal, so the body is already halfway there. The difference lies in which direction we let it point us.

Over a lifetime, the cost of shrinking adds up. Psychologists Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Husted Medvec found that in the short term, people tend to regret the things they did. Looking back over the long run, they regret far more the things they didn't do.

The discomfort that comes from living in alignment with our truth is always worth it.

Why expansion is so hard to choose

So why is expansion so hard to choose? Partly because the world around us is built to keep us in the safe zone. Advice from people who love us, the status quo, what society tells us success looks like... all of it tends to pull us back toward the familiar. Usually there's no bad intention in it. When you change, it asks the people around you to look at their own lives, and that can be uncomfortable. Housden makes a point I underlined: real change usually requires a break with the past, because a deeper truth has a hard time being heard under years of habit and conformity.

I also want to be realistic about the fact that a bold move isn't equally available to everyone at every moment. Sometimes the first step is small: a hard conversation, a no, an hour protected on a Saturday morning. It still counts.

Hearing the soul nudge

So how do we hear what's true for us? For me, it starts with getting quiet enough to listen beyond my mind. It usually takes a few hours on a weekend morning in my thinking corner, reading and reflecting, until I get past my racing thoughts and mental clutter to a place of real inner peace. From there, I can think honestly about who I am and what I really want.

And then the soul nudge comes. It doesn't arrive through a mental process. A choice or an insight about what to do simply appears, almost outside of ordinary time and space. Housden describes this kind of knowing in nearly the same way, and I've felt it many times. A nudge that comes from your soul is one worth listening to.

Taking the first step

But the knowing is only the beginning. As Housden puts it, knowing isn't enough; we have to begin. The first step is usually the hardest, and it takes trust, because we can't see what's on the other side of it.

Stepping onto a completely new path might first show you new ground, flowers and trees you've never seen. Then maybe a river or a mountain you never knew was there. And eventually, a destination you've never been to. We don't need to know the destination. We only need to know that the first step is in alignment with our inner truth, and then approach the path with trust and curiosity, almost a sense of wonder about what might unfold.

A nudge that comes from your soul is one worth listening to.

What this means for leaders in workplaces

I think about this as a leader, too. Every organization is full of people who have felt a soul nudge and are deciding whether to follow it, and most workplaces can't tell the difference between the anxiety that holds people back and the discomfort of growth. Our cultures either make room for expansion, or they quietly train people to shrink. I believe a society that paid attention to how many of its people are living lives true to themselves would look very different from the one we've built... and far more alive.

Danielle Posa

Want these ideas on your stage?

See speaking topics